Our Story
Since 2004,
Since 2004,
Emmitsburg’s Italian kitchen
Carleo Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria sits on the Silo Hill strip in Emmitsburg, Maryland — a small dining room, a busy takeout counter, and a menu built to feed a town.
What people tell their friends
Reviewer Favorite
Homemade lasagna
The meat lover’s lasagna gets named in review after review — huge portions, with salad and an Italian bread loaf alongside.
Reviewer Favorite
Steak & cheese subs
The hoagie that built the reputation — plus steak & cheese fries for the full experience.
The Sauce
A little sweeter
Our pizza sauce leans a touch sweet — it’s the flavor regulars grew up on and visitors remember.
The People
Friendly staff
A family-run room where the staff knows the orders — and the names — of the regulars.
Four ways to eat Carleo
Dine-InA small, friendly dining room on Silo Hill
TakeoutCall ahead — takeout is our love language
Delivery4:00 – 9:30 PM · Wednesdays from 1:00 PM
CateringCall 301-447-1999 to plan it